Honestly, I've always hated the new stuff and, for some reason, I didn't buy WCFYA until yesterday. And this is easily the best John Bush album. This album seems a lot less cookie-cutter than the last two and takes more chances.
I didn't like Any Place But Here at first, but it grew on me at the second hearing.
The only things I didn't like about this album were they still flirt with straight rock (in a bad way), and John Bush only sings at two levels loud and louder (honestly, my throat hurts just from listening to it. He must have a throat of iron. Stop the abuse! Free John Bush!).
What I like about this album is it really brings a lot of things together. You can feel a lot of different influences working to make something very original. The songs sound a lot more polished.
As a fan since the Among the Living days, the best compliment I can give is I like this album and wish I had bought it earlier.
EDIT: Doh