I absolutely love GF. Constitution of Treason is my all time favorite album, and I love Gone Forever as well, but I think Earth's Blood is a bit generic and bland in places, I can hear that they are trying new things musically which I respect, it works most of the time, but to me I love some bits then I find other bits generic, for me it doesn't have the same magic and consistency of the previous two albums. I'm not a huge fan of the rhythm guitar tone on this record, but the drums sound really big.
So I have slightly mixed feelings, but I'll probably end up loving it more when I've listen to it more times. Tell you what though, I do like listening to 'The New Clear'