Harvest tab

[Alex78]

so I found this tab for Harvest, and I'm wondering why it is completely different to Wankerness' one...see here the first part:

I.repeat 4 times
Acoustic guitar
|--0-----0-----0-----0-----0-----0-----0-----0-------|
|--0-----0-0---0-----0-0---0-----0-0---0-----0-0-----|
|--0-----0-0-0-0-----0-0-0-0-----0-0-0-0-----0-0-0---|
|--2-------2-2-2-------2-2-5-------5-5-0-------2-2---|
|--2-----------2-----------2-----------2-------------|
|--0-----------0-----------0-----------0-------------|


so which is the right one? help out a guitar noob here thanks!

 

[GraveyardVision]

nope, it's totally wrong
I'll look for the correct tab..

 

[wankerness]

I never tabbed that song, I just made a few corrections to one by some guy named Anton Lindstrom. That's the good tab, it's on powertabs.net. The one you posted right there is by someone with bad ears.

http://www.powertabs.net/tablature-0816/opeth-harvest-8140.ptb

There's the good tab, you'll need power tab editor to open it. www.power-tab.net

 

[Alex78]

thanks!

 

[antipunx13]

I don't mean to be over-critical or anything...but that powertab has a few errors as well. Good tab though...

 

[wankerness]

I don't mean to be over-critical or anything...but that powertab has a few errors as well. Good tab though...

Correct it with evidence or stfu imho

It was made before the dvd was available and I don't like the song enough to correct it against that.

 

[Arjen W.]

Some things I know of (opening riff and second chord of the chorus):

Opening riff

|--0--0-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0--|
|--0--0-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0--|
|--0--0-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0--|
|--2--2-2-2-2----2--2-2-2-2----2--2-2-2-2----4--4-5-5-5--|
|--2--2-2-2-2----2--2-2-2-2----2--2-2-2-2----5--5-7-7-7--|
|--0--0-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0----2--2-0-0-0----0--0-0-0-0--|
                               ^ this note, something like that

Chorus

|--0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0---|
|--0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0---|
|--9---9--9--9--9-----9---9--9--9--9-----9---9--9--9--9-----9---9--9--9--9---|
|--10--10-10-10-10----10--10-10-10-10----10--10-10-10-10----10--10-10-10-10--|
|--0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0---|
|----------------------------------------------------------------------------|

|--0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--------0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0---|
|--0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--------0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0---|
|--0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--------0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0---|
|--9---9--9--9--9-----9---9--9--9-h10----9---9--9--9--9-----9---9--9--9--9---|
|--10--10-10-10-10----10--10-10-10-------10--10-10-10-10----10--10-10-10-10--|
|--0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--------0---0--0--0--0-----0---0--0--0--0---|

Both can be seen quite easily on the Harvest video.

 

[antipunx13]

Correct it with evidence or stfu imho

It was made before the dvd was available and I don't like the song enough to correct it against that.

Haha...wow. A bit defensive, even after I said it was a good tab...Maybe I will correct it, but it'll be a Guitarpro file.

Arjen corrected a couple of the few parts I was talking about.

 

[wankerness]

Haha...wow. A bit defensive, even after I said it was a good tab...Maybe I will correct it, but it'll be a Guitarpro file.

Arjen corrected a couple of the few parts I was talking about.

Not defensive, I just fucking hate it when people who don't have a clue what they're talking about (not necessarily you, I'm just so used to it happening that I assume everyone who doesn't give specific examples immediately is stupid) are like LOL IT'S WRONG HERE IS THA RITE TAB *insert something absolutely horrible and blatantly wrong." I'm totally happy with corrections if they sound more right to me, like the ones the guy just pasted here, but if they're just going to go IT'S WRONG I'M NOT SAYING WHERE OR HOW CAUSE I AM ACTUALLY A TONE DEAF IDIOT I would rather they jump off a tall cliff. Regardless, I have no access to that tab file on powertabs.net cause it was mainly made by the other guy so you'd have to send them to him, still, good to know.

 

[antipunx13]

Not defensive, I just fucking hate it when people who don't have a clue what they're talking about (not necessarily you, I'm just so used to it happening that I assume everyone who doesn't give specific examples immediately is stupid) are like LOL IT'S WRONG HERE IS THA RITE TAB *insert something absolutely horrible and blatantly wrong." I'm totally happy with corrections if they sound more right to me, like the ones the guy just pasted here, but if they're just going to go IT'S WRONG I'M NOT SAYING WHERE OR HOW CAUSE I AM ACTUALLY A TONE DEAF IDIOT I would rather they jump off a tall cliff. Regardless, I have no access to that tab file on powertabs.net cause it was mainly made by the other guy so you'd have to send them to him, still, good to know.

ok...well rest assured that I'm not a tone deaf idiot. I've made a few tabs and even posted them on mysongbook before it became useless (Baying of the Hounds and Beneath the Mire). I would have posted corrections, but I don't really have the patience to type them out like the OP did...didn't mean to come off as an ignorant asshole...

 

[wankerness]

Yeah, W/e, I didn't even tab that song. I basically just skimmed it when he sent it to me and noticed that he had the entire intro riff as an Em, so I added the 45-57 upwards chord thing, and then pasted that through the rest of the tab, but besides that I sure didn't mess with it at all. So, like I said, give me all the corrections and I'll stick them in there if they sound right and send it to him.