Helloween's Keeper Of The Seven Rings Part 1 or Part 2?

[Wicked Child]

The age old question. Which one of Helloween's two undeniable classics reign supreme?
Although I think these two albums are two of the best albums in all of power metal, I like part 2 just a little bit more.

 

[delize]

Really!

I like part 1 better.

 

[coronerox]

Yeah, me too, part 1!

 

[TheGraveDigger]

I like Part 2 a little bit better but Part 1 has the song "Halloween" on it which is just fucking incredible. Speaking of Helloween I bought their "Time Of The Oath" cd today which is great.

 

[Insania]

My screen name should tell you which one I prefer...

 

[wolf]

Pt.1 I thought some of the choruses for Pt.2 were very commercial.

 

[_Zsuzsa_]

Part 1 because of Halloween.

 

[union9]

Well, I only ever owned 3 Halloween albums in my life. Those being Keeper...part 2, Walls of Jerhico and Pink Bubbles Go Ape (very gay). So my vote naturally goes for part 2. I've never heard the first.

 

[anvil(old)]

Part 2 is my favourite but they both

 

[TheGraveDigger]

Well, I only ever owned 3 Halloween albums in my life. Those being Keeper...part 2, Walls of Jerhico and Pink Bubbles Go Ape (very gay). So my vote naturally goes for part 2. I've never heard the first.

I suggest picking up Part 1 when you get a chance. Not only is it a great album but I would own it soley for the epic 13 minute masterpiece "Halloween". That is my favorite Helloween song ever.

 

[Orion Crystal Ice]

Keeper 1, cause Keeper 2 has a filler here and there and part 1 has none, but they're both essential.

And am I the only one here who loves the Chameleon album?

 

[Fangface]

Part 1 has less fillers, but Part 2 has most of the highlights, so I can't really choose between them...