I have to admit that I'm not that impressed with it on the first listen. Too much guitar widdling which just does nothing for me and I haven't found anything really memorable about it as yet. That is just my first impression but maybe that opinion will change after repeated listens.
yeah its a grower. I already listened to it like 15 times so it doesn't need to grow any more on me!
I'm with Jenna. Listened to it last night and was pretty disappointed. I'll give it another listen tonight, but it so far it's like United Abominations II to me.