Well, honestly I have always been on the fence with this band and have never been a huge fan -- although I did enjoy Tyranny. With that said, I really think the new CD could be one of their best! No offense to Mike, but I actually prefer the new singer (not trying to piss on the man's grave people - just stating my personal preference). And I REALLY like the track with Clay from Suspyre snging on it!
As far as Chris Ingles not playing, sorry I don't miss him one bit. I was just listening yesterday and I am personally blown away that Gary is not only such a strong guitarist, but man that boy can really play the piano!! He is unaturally accomplished on both instruments. And I had heard from someone who is personal friends with Gary about Joe being really busy and that Gary played drums for those tracks. Holy crap! Is there anything he can't do? And to top it off, when I met him back in May, he is a seriously nice guy! No egos with that guy.
For anyone that likes SG, I think they will be happy with this disk. For anyone that just likes prog rock/metal done well, they will also like it. I recommend it, go support Shadow Gallery!