Please critique my tones/mixes!

X14Halo

Member
May 28, 2010
135
0
16
I am completely new to mixing and recording, so I am looking for as much feedback as I can to help improve my mixes. I have 3 different clips, each of them with a different guitar tone and different mixes. Please let me know if there is one that you like the sound of or what could be improved. All different styles.

https://dl.dropbox.com/u/44864413/Ian_comp2.mp3

https://dl.dropbox.com/u/44864413/Ian_comp3.mp3

https://dl.dropbox.com/u/44864413/Ian_comp5.mp3


Basically for all of them I am recording from my Axe-FX II straight into Reaper using USB cable. Double tracking panned L and R 100%. Bass is coming from my attempt at a bass patch on my regular guitar also through the Axe-FX. (Sound of the bass is probably nowhere where it needs to be since I am not using a bass guitar...). And drums are Steven Slate drums 4.

My general workflow seems to be to put a high/low pass on the guitars, and then narrowly notch out any frequencies that seem harsh to me, followed by a small amount of low-mid compression. Then I put a bass boost on the bass guitar (maxxBass plugin). As for drums, I think I boosted the bass on the kickdrum and added some reverb to the snare and toms. Then I would group everything and use a limiter and Gclip. Any thing I am doing wrong here?