What sound would you use ?

[fremen]

I'm finalising the mix on a home made album. Right now my only problem is that I can decide what rythm guitar sound to use, between my guitar amp (recorded with a sm 57), Amplitube 2 with its own cabs, and Amplitube 2 with impulses. So I made three different mixes, hoping to have some feedback from users here
here they are :

http://pages.intnet.mu/fremen/Mp3s/LABOGA.mp3 (real amp, alas it's not a hi gain one)

http://pages.intnet.mu/fremen/Mp3s/Amplitube.mp3 (Amplitube 2)

http://pages.intnet.mu/fremen/Mp3s/Impulses.mp3 (Amplitube 2 with cabs off and guitarhack impulses)

So what do you think ? The mix is not finalized, I must work on the lead guitars, drums etc. If you have suggestions on the equalization of the guitars, I'll be your humble servant

 

[KeithRT99]

i would say impulse>amplitube>real.

 

[AudioPhile777]

I would say try combining the first and third... maybe use the real amp for the leads... and bring in some more mids for the rhythm part...

 

[Erik Monsonis]

Really good music!!

I'd say try with the Laboga>GuitarHack

From the ones you posted, i'd pick Amplitube with Impulses

 

[fremen]

Hi guys, thanks for your comments. At first I didn't think that the amplitube+impulses was the best combo, but you're all right, it is.

here's another song :
http://pages.intnet.mu/fremen/Mp3s/Fountain_mix8.mp3

Amplitube 2 on the left, Revalver MKII on the right, both with guitarhack impulses, please comment on the rythm guitar sound, the whole mix, and the song