What's with all this emo shit in metal these days

RETIREDTrapped

New Metal Member
Sep 12, 2001
8,312
4
0
What a fucking joke.

Iced Earth's lyrics are rediculous, always have been. It's songs like Blessed be you and Watching over me that REALLY SNAG MY SHIRT. Fucking emo bullshit "awwwwoooowwwooowww i'm so saaaaad, we'll be togerther in homosexual matrimony... boo hoo" fucking crap.

The only band who can pull the emotional thing off, and still retain my respect, is nevermore... because wd is poetic about it "Dark rivers carve the years between the lines of self control" goddamn, good lyricist. unlike SCHAFFER the dumbass.
 
heh.....if i want "depressant/emotional" music i'll go snag my stabbing westward or NIN cds......or some shit like that...


i can't stand those Iced Earth songs though....my friends dig em though.....my guitarists.......**shudders**

i can't STANDS IT I SAYS!

its no fun when i want like.... a more thrashy/death band....when one guy is always "binging" on a certain "brand" of music that fluxuates constantly(but i think he'll follow in my vision) and my other guy wants to go kinda helloween powermetal shit.....cept more uh...."neo-classical"......which is ok to listen to time n time again....but i can't see myself playing that shit....i think he wants to cover Watching Over Me.....and prolly some old 70s rock or something..........its a ray of hope for me when he suggests ATG or Carcass...or slayer or something more....me


it hurts me to think i might have to just start a NEW band w/o my lead guitarist/very close friend (the powermetal guy)


i think the "binger" is always playing "I Died For You" on his acoustic......luckily right now he's binging on like Type O Negative......which is more up my alley
 
Dante's Inferno, Dark Saga = \m/

Haven't heard the ones you're talking about.
 
Just because some one sings about things you consider "weak" doesn't mean that they are lame. We are talking about the fucking Earth. Iced Fucking Earth. You won't admit it, but no human being is entirely hard hearted. So fucking play it off like you hate it while you ignorantly ingnore your humanity and call it "we'll be togerther in homosexual matrimony". Its not like they are Def Lepard or anything. Haven't you ever heard Pure Evil. As a nevermore and ie fan i'm sick of this comparison bullshit man. They are both good bands. I think nevermore is one of the heaviest bands in existence. I mean listen to POE. Thats in Eb Tuning and that album puts hair on my balls. Nevermore would never play something like stormrider or wolf, nor would the ie boys play tianemen man or this sacramant. Besides, I don't know if you play in a band but IE is damn good live and thats a feat initself.
 
Everyone gives Iced Earth too hard of a fucking time around here. I don't know why, but you do. That song meant a lot to Jon, it was about his friend who died and hell, it doesn't really matter what the lyrics are, Barlow puts so much emotion into it that he could sell it singing "hahoujklnjhjkjlh;jl;j". Of course I don't know how he would pronounce that or the semicolons. And hell, what do you not get about emotion in Metal? Isn't that what Metal is about, emotion. Anger, depression, hatred, etc.......I always thought that that is what Metal is all about, emotion.
 
God, sometimes I get so tired of ppl here. You all seem to be these ignorant metalshitguys who can ONLY listen to metal and nothing else and as soon as there's some emotion you have to bash it. Somedays I really hate 99% of all the metalheads. Immature fuckheads. Excuse my language, but I'm so sick off it.

Can't everyone just ignore what damn genre a band/artist is in and just enjoy the damn music? Music ain't genres. Music is EMOTION.


NP - Godpees You Black Emperor! - Static
 
While Iced Earth's lyrics aren't up to par with Nevermore (not many bands' are), I can't believe you think they are horrible. When I think of horrible lyrics, I think of grindcore, black metal, pop, country, rap, etc. Those are horrible lyrics. Iced Earth are simply decent lyrics in above average metal, I can dig it.
 
Just because some one sings about things you consider "weak" doesn't mean that they are lame. We are talking about the fucking Earth. Iced Fucking Earth. You won't admit it, but no human being is entirely hard hearted. So fucking play it off like you hate it while you ignorantly ingnore your humanity and call it "we'll be togerther in homosexual matrimony". Its not like they are Def Lepard or anything. Haven't you ever heard Pure Evil. As a nevermore and ie fan i'm sick of this comparison bullshit man. They are both good bands. I think nevermore is one of the heaviest bands in existence. I mean listen to POE. Thats in Eb Tuning and that album puts hair on my balls. Nevermore would never play something like stormrider or wolf, nor would the ie boys play tianemen man or this sacramant. Besides, I don't know if you play in a band but IE is damn good live and thats a feat initself.

*sigh*

Some people just don't get it.

Yes, i guess my post was a little harsh, but hey. I say it like it is, and always do.

Now first of all, i didn't compare IE to Nevermore. I never do, they have nothing to compare to each other, they play totally different styles of music. The only reference to nevermore that i made, was saying that WD was one of the few people that can write emotional lyrics without it coming across as sappy, and lame.

I really love Iced Earth's music, they are a damn cool band. And i love barlow's voice, why can't you goddamn listen to what i'm saying before you jump down my throat for fuck's sake? i LIKE iced earth, i just think their lyrics are plain dumb, and the songs that utilize the "well be together again" style lyrics are extremely weak, and almost radio songs, like Watching over me.

I don't really understand how a band can go from a three chord song like that into THE COMING CURSE :rock: in the course of one album, it's thoroughly bizarre.

Everyone gives Iced Earth too hard of a fucking time around here. I don't know why, but you do. That song meant a lot to Jon, it was about his friend who died and hell, it doesn't really matter what the lyrics are, Barlow puts so much emotion into it that he could sell it singing "hahoujklnjhjkjlh;jl;j". Of course I don't know how he would pronounce that or the semicolons. And hell, what do you not get about emotion in Metal? Isn't that what Metal is about, emotion. Anger, depression, hatred, etc.......I always thought that that is what Metal is all about, emotion.

Yes, i respect that the song was about john's freind... but for god's sake, the dude got drunk and rode home on a motorbike, what a loser.

Maybe that's what metal is about to YOU, yes. But not to me. Not in any way whatsoever. Metal is about creating something, like a journey, crafting a path for the listener in terms of music, the lyrics, like Death's "Perennial Quest" or Nevermore's "The Learning", Intense musicianship at it's peak, the music tells the story, and the lyrics are a totally different faction, that should add to the music. It is about that, AND the relentless persuit of your dreams.

While Iced Earth's lyrics aren't up to par with Nevermore (not many bands' are), I can't believe you think they are horrible. When I think of horrible lyrics, I think of grindcore, black metal, pop, country, rap, etc. Those are horrible lyrics. Iced Earth are simply decent lyrics in above average metal, I can dig it.

Rap, Country, Pop... yes, but you only say that about Black Metal (uh, i don't even know what grindcore is?? Is that stuff like Napalm Death etc? I don't even listen to those bands... so *shrug*), because you don't listen to it, and the bands that you HAVE listened to would be the rediculously stupid one's like Mayhem. Actually jimbob, i think you'd like Dimmu Borgir's "Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia", it's thrash, and there is some cool stuff in the lyrics here and there. You should check out the song "Kings of the carnival creation", you might/might not dig it. I love it, and i'm a self confessed hater of even the slightest tinge of blackmetal, corpspaint, or blast beats.

"Consuming illusions made from hysteria and swallowed tongues
Devoured by doubt, conducting arts of misconception
Testimonial sufficiency declaring numbness of all perceptions"

That's my favourite line from the album, it's just so damn good. *shrug*

Anyway.

As a nevermore and ie fan i'm sick of this comparison bullshit man. They are both good bands. I think nevermore is one of the heaviest bands in existence. I mean listen to POE. Thats in Eb Tuning and that album puts hair on my balls. Nevermore would never play something like stormrider or wolf, nor would the ie boys play tianemen man or this sacramant. Besides, I don't know if you play in a band but IE is damn good live and thats a feat initself.

godfuckingDAMMIT. I said absolutely nothing in my post about the music in EITHER band. FUCK! I like both bands, and i think they both have their merits, but goddamn, i didn't even bring this shit up. What is with you people making assumptions?
 
So angry! Why so angry? Trapped, stop making a spectacle of yourself and ignore the things you don't like. What have you accomplished by starting this thread? Mass confusion and aimless hatred, now get over yourself...go back to positively analyzing Warrel's lyrics or something.

np - UDO
 
Originally posted by Lord of Metal
....And hell, what do you not get about emotion in Metal? Isn't that what Metal is about, emotion. Anger, depression, hatred, etc.......I always thought that that is what Metal is all about, emotion.

I agree - if a band can't really touch any kinda emotion in me, I never listen to them!