best black metal band - round 2

[sexualist death]

yep... again
what do you think guys?

 

[Torgoth]

Fucking hard to decide but I voted Emperor.

 

[sexualist death]

yes, it's very hard today... i voted to limbonic art but if i voted again it will be to setherial

 

[Thanatos]

Darkthrone

 

[_A_SCARLET_SUNSET_]

emperor, but it was a really hard pick between emperor and hecate enthroned

 

[Fractured]

Emperor, it was between them and Darkthrone.

 

[NAD]

Dissection!!!

 

[sexualist death]

again.... dissection it's not just black metal..
dissection is death black..

 

[NAD]

Originally posted by sexualist death
again.... dissection it's not just black metal..
dissection is death black..

Yet Bal-Sagoth is pure black metal, eh?

 

[sexualist death]

yes it is.

 

[sh0kr0k]

Ah this is better, I know most of these bands now

While I simply adore Bal-Sagoth and Emperor, I had to go with SATYRICON!!! \m/

 

[NAD]

Bal-sagoth is symphonic black, if you're getting all subsubgenre about it.

Semantics, either way I voted for Dimmu Borgir.

 

[sexualist death]

yes, bla-sagoth it is symphonic black metal but this is one of a lot black metal style so it is black metal.
different and very special.. but still black metal

 

[NAD]

So symphonic black counts as black metal, but death black (or whatever you called Dissection) doesn't?

 

[sexualist death]

symphonic black metal it's still black metal, and all the styles that existent in the black metal.. brutal black metal and melodic black metal and technical and bla bla....
but it's like the brutal death metal and melodic death metal and technical.......

bal-sagoth it is black metal, the symphonic is just the melody of the band.. but it is black.

 

[kamikaze]

Its no guess as to where my vote went, Thanks Tal

 

[sexualist death]

dont thank me...
it's just a poll..

 

[kamikaze]

Well at least you put the founding fathers on there damn it

 

[sexualist death]

yep ....

 

[NAD]

Originally posted by sexualist death
symphonic black metal it's still black metal, and all the styles that existent in the black metal.. brutal black metal and melodic black metal and technical and bla bla....
but it's like the brutal death metal and melodic death metal and technical.......

bal-sagoth it is black metal, the symphonic is just the melody of the band.. but it is black.

Okay then I'll agree Bal-Sagoth belongs on the list, but I'll still argue that using that logic qualifies Dissection as black metal as well.