I don't have a favorite album, because so many of them are hit-or-miss for me, but I do have a favorite song: Where The Rain Grows from Master of The Rings.
A friend from Japan put it on a mix tape for me in like 1995 and it blew me away. However, he and left off all the band names and song names from the tape so I didn't know what was what (also where I first heard In Flames, Edge of Sanity, and Dissection and not knowing who they were but enjoying the songs immensely). When he told me it was Helloween I was floored because the last thing I'd heard was Keepers II, since this was during the time Noise pulled out of the US, and when people were just starting to really use the Internet to promote/communicate metal. Oh yeah, he also put Gamma Ray's Man on a Mission on there which also floored me because the last thing I heard by them was from the first album with Ralf.
</ramble>.