taken from amazon.ca
"I firmly agree with the previous poster who called this album "mediocre". Perfect choice of words- this album is, indeed, quite mediocre. Of course, the post-Waters albums are worse than this, but that's not saying much. This album is total crap. CRAPOLA. The vocals are wooden and uninteresting, with warmed-over 70's heavy metal. Obviously, "Pigs on the Wing" 1 & 2 is nice, but as has been pointed out, can be obtained on the Internet in combined form. Of the three central compositions, "Pigs" is the only very listenable track, but like the others, it suffers from its needless length. "Dogs" is absurdly turgid, and "Sheep" is unconvincing and ill-concieved. When you come down to it, this album is nothing more than three insanely bloated compositions that would've been better as five-minute songs each. Avoid."
"I firmly agree with the previous poster who called this album "mediocre". Perfect choice of words- this album is, indeed, quite mediocre. Of course, the post-Waters albums are worse than this, but that's not saying much. This album is total crap. CRAPOLA. The vocals are wooden and uninteresting, with warmed-over 70's heavy metal. Obviously, "Pigs on the Wing" 1 & 2 is nice, but as has been pointed out, can be obtained on the Internet in combined form. Of the three central compositions, "Pigs" is the only very listenable track, but like the others, it suffers from its needless length. "Dogs" is absurdly turgid, and "Sheep" is unconvincing and ill-concieved. When you come down to it, this album is nothing more than three insanely bloated compositions that would've been better as five-minute songs each. Avoid."
