Kill Em All = FAN FUCKING TASTIC!
Ride the Lightning = OMG CUMS, the best of the best.
Master of Puppets = Not as good as RtL IMO, its quite good though.
...and Justice For All = WOW, great stuff, except the no bass thing.
The Black Album = Rather semi-decent, often boring, overall Metallica could do ALOT better.
Load = Kill me now, so so so so so so so so shit, fuck I can't even get past the first few songs in their entirety its so bad...URGGGHHHH...HOW CAN PEOPLE LIKE THIS PIECE OF SHIT!!???
Re-Load = I personally feel this is ALOT better than Load, its songs are slightly more menacing, but it's STILL retarted dumb-arse southern rock. MUCH MUCH better than Load, and yet, still pretty crap.
S&M = Some good shit (namely the older songs), mixed in with some utter bullshit (namely the newer songs)
Tis sad what happened to the 'tallica...