Guys, how many times do we have to have this debate? This is all subjective. One tone you might think is amazing just might sound like ass to someone else.
If you listen to it on some decent studio monitors or headphones at a decent volume you can hear that it's just reverb mostly. As other people have said though there may be some phasing issues giving it that weird tone.
You may also get the same tone by using an octo reverb mixed with a real fat Hall or cavern echo/reverb.