I don't get it either, but at this point I just shrug my shoulders and move on. Personally, I'm a big fan of a cappella music, and while Van Canto probably isn't the most amazing example of the genre (in that they use a drummer), they are definitely interesting for playing in this genre. I find the argument of "if they used instruments they wouldn't be anything special" really beside the point.
more musical goodness....
- Thread starter TwizstedJesus
- Start date
I don't get it either, but at this point I just shrug my shoulders and move on. Personally, I'm a big fan of a cappella music, and while Van Canto probably isn't the most amazing example of the genre (in that they use a drummer), they are definitely interesting for playing in this genre. I find the argument of "if they used instruments they wouldn't be anything special" really beside the point.
Palabra de Dios
Heavy Metal Weatherman
While I guess I understand the novelty appeal of this band, I just don't like them at all really. It's kind of the way I feel about Apocalyptica. I know what they're doing...it's just not interesting to me.
5150
Member
Wow, was the personal attack really necessary? I questioned what I thought was a hypocritical statement regarding a style of music. You responded with a valid answer but then chose to make it nasty. I truly was not trying to take a personal shot at you.
Anyway, back on topic, based on your response, it's not a cappella music that you find distasteful but rather Van Canto in general. Which is fine, as you have pointed out many times, people are allowed to post their musical opinions.
Personally, I see little difference in the a cappella voice of Enya vs. Van Canto's singers as a valid "instrument". Either is interesting and fun in small doses.
I'll end by saying I truly wish you and the wife well. Stay warm and safe in that deep freeze coming your way.
Harvester
The Promoter
Honestly, I wouldn't consider my reply nasty and sorry you took as such. It was just a friendly jab back using a bit of black humor based on your frequent geriatric musical preferences ( I KID! I KID!) and our illustrious history together. I don't even know your age. 
You have always been a supporter of the festival even when you don't like the majority of the bands booked and I appreciate it.
To further clarify the issue.... It's all about the context of A Capella. It could be in a Celtic atmosphere or the harmonies on Seven Bridges Road and I will go apeshit over it.. I draw the line at the gimmick of using your voice as a musical instrument like Van Canto does. It's gloried beat-boxing to me. They are very talented at what the do and I can appreciate the skill involved. That doesn't mean I still don't think it sucks though.
I appreciate the end note. We are hunkered down awaiting that crap that just passed through your state.
You have always been a supporter of the festival even when you don't like the majority of the bands booked and I appreciate it. To further clarify the issue.... It's all about the context of A Capella. It could be in a Celtic atmosphere or the harmonies on Seven Bridges Road and I will go apeshit over it.. I draw the line at the gimmick of using your voice as a musical instrument like Van Canto does. It's gloried beat-boxing to me. They are very talented at what the do and I can appreciate the skill involved. That doesn't mean I still don't think it sucks though.
I appreciate the end note. We are hunkered down awaiting that crap that just passed through your state.
J-Dubya 777
It NEVER ends
Bringing a little Wisconsin to all my friends down South. :Smokedev:
Seriously though, be safe everyone, that's alotta ice they are predicting even by (damn) Yankee standards....
Seriously though, be safe everyone, that's alotta ice they are predicting even by (damn) Yankee standards....
TENTH DREAMER DECEIVER
Halcyon Way Sufferer
- Jan 7, 2002
- 3,859
- 3
- 38
