Need Some Unbiased Ears for a Cabinet Impulse A/B

[Frak]

Hey guys,

I've been using the same cabinet impulse for a very long time now. I've decided
to try out a few different ones, and I think I may have found one I like better
(after scavenging through countless packs).

I was wondering if someone could listen to this short clip A/Bing the two and let
me know which one they prefer. Please excuse the dodgy playing, they were
just super rough takes to test the voicing of the impulses.

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/21735317/Cabinet A-B.wav

Thanks!

 

[texisthebest]

I don't know if I have unbiased ears but the second one sounds better to me (less fizzy maybe).
Anyway the two of them sound good and maybe you should put them in a mix to see better the whole thing.

 

[Frak]

I don't know if I have unbiased ears but the second one sounds better to me (less fizzy maybe).
Anyway the two of them sound good and maybe you should put them in a mix to see better the whole thing.

Hahah by "unbiased ears" I meant any pair of ears that aren't mine really.
I was just worried that I only liked the new one better because it was something different.
Yeah, good idea, I'll put it in a mix and track the riff a little better so I can get a better idea I guess.
I'll post the results here so I can get other's opinions.