New better than old

[Demilich]

Mike's growl > Peter's growl... and I don't listen to either of their bands, so fuck off!

 

[Lord_AgathoN]

Yeah fuck off.........you are a stupid kid. They wont kick each other asses you smartmark.......and comparing their growls has nothing to do with the weight or the hair (btw. you ugly fag).

 

[One Winged Angel]

You have to do better than that.

 

[Birkenau]

10. If their growls could take possesion of 100 foot tall robot warriors, Peter's robot would destroy Mike's simply because there is just that much more to Peter's growl

Gawd you're a newb, Mikeal's robot would PWN Peter's, therefore nullifying everything else you said.

 

[Jinn]

There are a few things I've noticed about their two styles of growling. Here I will objectively compare them, but in the end people should just choose which one they like best based on which one appeals to them more, for whatever personal reason they have.

Here goes nothing:

1. Peter has more range, and can do more with his growl
2. Mike has a more consistant, lower growl
3. Peter's growl is just as beastly as Mike's
3. Mike's clean vocals should not be taken into consideration, as this is a discussion of Bloodbath/growls
4. Peter can actually achieve a low end growl like Mike's, and because it is more raspy, it is actually more beastly than Mikes
5. The reason Peter doesn't spend his entire time in Bloodbath at a low end growl is because he realizes that it's very boring and would show a lot less emotion/scariness
6. Peter is scary and evil but Mike is cuddly like a teddy bear
7. Peter's hair is nicer than Mike's
8. Although Mike outweighs Peter, Peter can still kick Mike's ass because it's mostly fat anyway
9. Mike is chubby
10. If their growls could take possesion of 100 foot tall robot warriors, Peter's robot would destroy Mike's simply because there is just that much more to Peter's growl
11. Peter's growl is better
12. Everyone should like Peter's growl more, because it's better
13. Only little girls like Mike's growl better anyway

So now that we all have the facts straight, it should be a lot easier for people to decide between these two great styles of growling.

*tsk*

1. What can Peter do? Scream high, scream low. good for him. He can't even TOUCH Mike's consistent low growl, and Mike can also sing high as well.
2. Nothing to argue.
3. Peter's growl is like a wolf's compared to mike's demonic lion.
3. [you have two three's] Yet you take Mike's body shape, hair, and looks into consideration. shaddup.
4. Rasping? stfu. anyone can rasp while growling. That's easy. What's harder is maintaining a lower growl while actually GROWLING, not rasping. Besides, there's a reason why the vocal technique is called 'growling' and not 'rasping'
5. Ever listened to a little masterpiece called "Ressurection Through Carnage" lately? The entire album was basically low growls, and it is one of if not the the most brutal death metal albums in history. I'd say that low growls are pretty fucking entertaining.
6. Who cares about how they look? Like you just said, this is about the growling. Mike's reputation as one of the most brutal growlers in the business has gained him the respect. He doesn't need to look scary to be good. I mean, Jesus... the guy has a 70's porn moustache!
7. irrellevant and one of the dumbest points I've ever read.
8. given, but then again, mike is a good guy, and has no reason to hold anything against Peter. He'd invite Peter over for a beer and to listen to some records.
9. Peter is ugly. what's your point?
10. Mike's robot warrior would break off all of Peter's robot warriors limbs and sibsequently shove them up Peter's robot's ass. Then it would decapitate the robot and drink it's motor oil while disemboweling the rest of it, all while roaring the lyrics to 'So You Die'.
11. No, not really.
12. Everyone should wake up and see that Mike is just that much better, no matter who they prefer. I prefer Anders Nystrom to say, Yngwie Malmsteen when talking guitarists. Yngwie can school Anders in shredding, but Anders is still my favorite guitarist.
13. little girls like stupid pop vocalists, like britney spears, christina aguilera, dani filth, and peter tagtgren.

pwnd.

 

[Demoke]

^well said!

 

[Lord_AgathoN]

haha, really ownt ^^ Thanks for making my day Jinn

 

[One Winged Angel]

Either everyone here has a twisted sense of humor, or nobody here understands that I made idiotic points like that because it's idiotic to say that one of their growls is better than the other. It's completely subjective. I assumed I could make a post like that and get a good response, but apparently to be clever you have to call people gay by showing them pictures of Letterman distinguishing flamers. I mean, for God's sake I was trying to make people laugh! So yeah, you got me good Jinn. Well played.

 

[Jinn]

Just helping to spread the laughter, friend

 

[Jinn]

And just a reminder: I am self-appointed asshole of these two forums [Katatonia and Bloodbath]. Any and all mean, hate-filled, spiteful, rude, vulgar or obscene remarks I make are jokes and nothing more. Every time I flame someone, it's a joke... unless I specify that it's not.

This is a lonely, god forsaken duty that I must bear... until...well.. for a bit at least ^_^;

 

[One Winged Angel]

Surely you must see that all you're doing by making valid counterpoints to my retarded ones is only reinforcing the thoughts of people who didn't get my post. Nobody's laughing but me, and you apparently.

Alright, you may carry on with the thread now. Sorry for interrupting.

[EDIT:] By the way, I wasn't worried about you, since I know you have a sense of humor. The whole reason I said those things was because of the picture you posted.

 

[Jinn]

What's wrong with leading the mindless on a little goose chase?

I see nothing wrong with it... and besides, it's all in good fun.

Whether you like Mike's vocals better or *cough*Peter's vocals better doesn't matter... but it does give us something to harass each other about until Bloodbath tours or something...

 

[One Winged Angel]

I just felt sad because everyone was agreeing with you and not me. Really, I just didn't get the response I thought I would get and I didn't know what to do. I'll remember your words for next time.

 

[Jinn]

only two people have agreed with me so far, and the only reason why is because they're on the "Mikeal Akerfeldt's growls make Peter Tagtgren look like a catholic school girl" side of this whole debate.

 

[Jinn]

[EDIT:] By the way, I wasn't worried about you, since I know you have a sense of humor. The whole reason I said those things was because of the picture you posted.

'Ey, I like that pic... it's funny in my opinion. I only did it to stir some shit up with the newbie.

I'm spamming the shit out of this thread... I'll stop now.

 

[One Winged Angel]

It's ok, we kind of destroyed the thread already.

 

[TrailofDeath]

It's alright One Winged Angel, personally I enjoy Peter's growls over Mikael's. But they both do a killer job in my mind.

 

[Baletempest]

This thread is Dead RIP, NEXT