They're alright but nothing more. I like that "We're In This Together" song by them on The Fragile. I think their new With Teeth album is tacky. I think the problem is most of his songs are rather predictable.
deliciously tacky, I find. Trent deals in cliche, he's a pop artist, not an evil ass metal dude. I guess it comes down to your definition of good, but I enjoy a good predictable collage of cliches & original material, as long as it is well done. NIN are, I find.