Please rate my drumsound (Acoustic Drums)

[MetalMiller]

Hi, this is my next try in getting a decent drumsound for a band i`m recording. The setup is the same like the one in this thread:

http://www.ultimatemetal.com/forum/...engl-fireball-acoustic-drums.html#post8045057

No bass and vocals yet. Guitar track is a still sloopy one i copy and paiste to a double track. Snare and kick are replaced. Snare sample is a mix of one behindert once posted and caliban snare. My chain on the drum bus was Waves v-comp, steinberg magneto, L1 and parelell compression with Sonalksis comp. A bit comp. and eq on every single track/bus.
Than mastered with g-clip, waves ssl400, camel crusher, C4, L3.
Am i on the right way or any fatal mistakes i don`t hear anymore.
I really need fresh ears, please give me feedback.

http://www.soundclick.com/util/getplayer.m3u?id=7355383&q=hi

 

[Glenn Fricker]

If they're replaced, they're not acoustic drums anymore, are they? It sounds nice, but I'd love to hear the miked snare.....

 

[MetalMiller]

Yes, kick and snare 100& % replaced. I´ve recorded some samples that i wanted to process with no luck. I think it`s hard to get an good snare sound out of a sm58. I´ve tried a md421 and both sm58 top/bottom md421 top/bottom too. But it is an very old model, with much to less gain. Have heard that the impedance of the first 421`s are not compatible with todays studio equipment and preamps... real shame.