Porcupine Tree - The Incident

[nomisofsiman]

So I just received and listened to the new Porcupine Tree album "The Incident" and I truly believe it is their magnum opus. A true musical journey that has just blown me away. I've probably listened to it at least five times by now. What do you guys think of it?

I seriously cannot wait to see them in concert come Tuesday. Hell yeah!!!!

 

[Prog_Please]

I didn't much care for the album. There are a couple parts of the song that I like, but for the most part it seems like a lot of filler surrounding a few good parts. The second disc is much better, however, it pales in comparison to "Fear of a Blank Planet," "Deadwing" and "In Absentia" (duh). "The Incident" did sound much better live though, so the concert was definitely a highlight.

 

[TribunalRecords]

it wasn't terrible but nothing new. Deadwing is still a favorite of mine. i think it's become difficult for bands to keep the spark of originality going after so many albums. personally, i am just coming to a point with so many bands saying "heard it." not in a bad way per say, but just in the fact that i need to spend more time with the albums i truly love by these bands and not just buying new stuff because it's new. it's not just with PT but with plenty of bands i dig. i guess i am getting older.

 

[KingsGene]

I didn't much care for the album. There are a couple parts of the song that I like, but for the most part it seems like a lot of filler surrounding a few good parts. The second disc is much better, however, it pales in comparison to "Fear of a Blank Planet," "Deadwing" and "In Absentia" (duh). "The Incident" did sound much better live though, so the concert was definitely a highlight.

So far, this is also my opinion after only a couple of spins but I have yet to give it the appropriate attention. I am excited about the live show as I am seeing them Tuesday night.

 

[AngraRULES]

I have still not digested the album properly. I guess I bought stuff at ProgPower that I'm enjoying a bit more.

So far, I like some of the stuff on it, but it hasn't hit the spot yet.

 

[end]

I have to say, their live performance of The Incident was pretty awesome. Overall I like the album so far, but I do need to listen to it more.

 

[digitalink]

So I just received and listened to the new Porcupine Tree album "The Incident" and I truly believe it is their magnum opus. A true musical journey that has just blown me away. I've probably listened to it at least five times by now. What do you guys think of it?

I seriously cannot wait to see them in concert come Tuesday. Hell yeah!!!!

After the first 4 spins it was clear to me that this one is as good as Deadwing or FOABP. It is different and a little more ambient, but I love it just as much. Caught their show at the Nokia in LA Saturday night, but I won't spoil it for you. All I have to say is ...

 

[AMBR]

After the first 4 spins it was clear to me that this one is as good as Deadwing or FOABP. It is different and a little more ambient, but I love it just as much. Caught their show at the Nokia in LA Saturday night, but I won't spoil it for you. All I have to say is ...

Awesome. I'll be at Terminal 5 Thursday in NYC. Anyone else?

 

[Kaosaur]

If there's still tickets left day of show, I'm there!

 

[MartinW]

I love The Incident, I think it's more even than, for example, In Absentia. I don't care for Circle of Manias, but other than that, it's all great.

 

[KingsGene]

The show in Chicago tonight was amazing. Sold out and packed to the rafters...

 

[KaptainKrude]

The show in Chicago tonight was amazing. Sold out and packed to the rafters...

Excellent show... and somewhat amusing to see all the puzzled looks on some people's faces over them playing The Incident complete, despite SW's saying so early on. *facepalm*

 

[nomisofsiman]

The show in Chicago tonight was amazing. Sold out and packed to the rafters...

It was truly an amazing experience. One of the last major acts that I truly feel I HAVE to see live. I love the new disc and them doing the title track in its entirety was incredible. The rest of the show was damn good as well. They're perfect live.

However, and I will get shit for this for sure, I think I was more blown away by King's X on a musical standpoint. Reason being that I think King's X did more than simply play their songs and improvised a little bit. Not saying Porcupine Tree wasn't fantastic, they were, but I'm always more impressed by bands who give you more than just playing their songs, you know? I wasn't even a fan of King's X before, but now I am for sure.

 

[shaq]

Awesome. I'll be at Terminal 5 Thursday in NYC. Anyone else?

I'll be seeing you there