If I was in your shoes, I would experiment here. It would be a flat out fun as hell, inventive, progressive way of getting things done. I would physically conduct in front of the band. If you did that, got in the zone with it and had fun, so would the band. If listening back to it, everyone is surprised how well it turned out, it would give that album production session such an awesome damn story. As a Producer/Engineer, if you surprise the crap out of everyone with what you do, and everyone is smiling from ear to ear, you got an awesome reputation, and a building career.
Producers do wierd friggin things sometimes. If you don't know that, then do your research on Master Producers. They do what they do with confidence, excitement, and dignity. Their recording business sees amazing results from that!