Scott Ian on S.O.D. (Blabbermouth post)

[Buzzard]

Charlie is replaceable

 

[johnnieCzech]

not........ Anthrax IMHO Didnt come as a force to be delt with until Spreading the disease and Among the Living and they kept it going until POT (which is one of the heaviest records EVER)
But as everyone has seen the once great Anthrax fell from being pioneers of metal to being just another band after getting rid of Joey...............

You´re right in a way. Which, of course, doesn´t affect my opinion.

 

[MyHatred]

Bostaph all the way..........makes me #3

I know there are some Slayer elitist's out there that would have my head on a stake for this but I could care less. I honestly think that Bostaph brought some much needed enthusiasm to Slayer..I love Slayer as much as any metal head does but lets face it, Lombardo's drumming was getting pretty stale before he left and I was not all that impressed this year with his drumming(he blows me out of the water but that goes w/o saying) at Ozzfest. I mean seriously, turn on Divine Intervention and listen to how insane Bostaph is on Killing Field's. When I first heard that album I was listening to it with my arm's crossed with a "who does this guy think he is?" "He can't replace Lombardo." type of attitude...Well by the end of the album my arms were no longer crossed, they were blown off by Bostaph's insane drum fills..Since then I have always prefered Bostaph era Slayer, even Undisputed Attitude(that's actually my favorite slayer album) which alot of Slayer fanatics despise.

 

[johnnieCzech]

Well in fact, John Dette plays drums on Undisputed Attitude as far as I´m concerned?
But I agree with you on that point.

 

[gaschamber]

lombardos better

 

[MyHatred]

Well in fact, John Dette plays drums on Undisputed Attitude as far as I´m concerned?
But I agree with you on that point.

Actually, that was Bostaph's last album before he left and eventually came back. Dette was just a touring drummer for when that album was released. Slayer booted John Dette out after that tour because he just couldn't hang...I'm sorry I have read one to many Metal Maniacs back in the day and I remember reading all of that.

 

[johnnieCzech]

Actually, that was Bostaph's last album before he left and eventually came back. Dette was just a touring drummer for when that album was released. Slayer booted John Dette out after that tour because he just couldn't hang...I'm sorry I have read one to many Metal Maniacs back in the day and I remember reading all of that.

OK, I was mistaken probably. I remember seeing one video from that and Dette was there.

 

[MyHatred]

Yeah, I seen that video too. It's "I hate you" and he(Dette) does play in the video...Bostaph left right after recording the album to play in some band called "Truth about Seafood". I guess it was supposed to be kinda like Primus, I haven't heard any of it though....I would really like to hear what Bostaph is capable of outside of metal.

 

[johnnieCzech]

Yeah I heard that Truth About Seafood was kind of jazz-pop mixture. Hmm, weird. I didn´t hear a single note so...I don´t know.

 

[Lordlindsey]

Charlie is replaceable

Not as easily as the singer.

 

[Buzzard]

Not as easily as the singer.

Tell that to Anthrax- Joey Belladonna was the band.
Watch SOD live- I am the band. I also take time to
spend with the fans, Unlike certain drummers i Know

 

[johnnieCzech]

Joey´s voice sucked ass except of Spreading The Disease.

 

[bobo'c]

Charlie is definitely replacable.The singer to me is the personality of the band. You can always find musicians to play the same way. But when it comes to the frontman it changes the whole sound and attitude of the band.To me Belladonna is Anthrax. Though I do like Bush era thrax it still doesn't sound like Anthrax to me. Some of its good but its not the Anthrax I grew up on. Oh and fuck you lordlindsey you fucking half a faggot. Don't talk shit about Billy or feel the wrath.