Scott or James?

[THEBALDGUYFROMBLACKLODGEVIDEO]

I say Scott...

 

[Stormwatch]

If you mean Jaymz Hetfield, I'd say Scott. Hetfield can lick my tadger all night, while listening to Load, Reload, S+M and St. Anger. That would, I imagine, be the worst version of hell ever envisaged.

 

[~blondie~]

scott

 

[Thrillho]

no offense, but all these "vs" threads latley have been absolute no-brainers.

Scott, no contest whatsoever.

 

[THEBALDGUYFROMBLACKLODGEVIDEO]

no offense, but all these "vs" threads latley have been absolute no-brainers..

None taken, you are absolutely right.

 

[Stormwatch]

I take offense to that.

 

[gerardomosh]

SCOTT!!!!

 

[Chemikill]

Jaymz owned all in the day

Today Scott wins

 

[prime666]

gay thread. Scott is the better vocalist by far.

 

[TacoBellJunkie]

Scott talks about stuff on VH1

Jaymz talks about his feeeeeelings

Advantage Scott.

 

[Dredd74]

I gotta go with James.

 

[DumbAss]

Are we Talking about James Hetfield or James Kirk, 'cause Kirk could kick Scott Ians Ass!!!!!
Sorry Scott, but you understand... it's Shatner for Gods sake!!!

 

[Boro the Beautiful]

Scott talks about stuff on VH1

Jaymz talks about his feeeeeelings

Advantage Scott.

15/0

 

[MetalThrasher442]

Scott Ian today by far, but in the 80's I think they were tied.

 

[nafnikufesin]

Are we Talking about James Hetfield or James Kirk, 'cause Kirk could kick Scott Ians Ass!!!!!
Sorry Scott, but you understand... it's Shatner for Gods sake!!!

Spoken like a true Canadian!

Shatner rules!

Forget Julio and Hasslehoff, Shatner should be Anthrax'snext vocalist!

 

[Mickenglanduk]

James has better socks but Scott has a better t-shirt

 

[Thrash fiend]

Have JAmes playing abilities deteriorated, or has scott gotten better?

 

[prime666]

I got to go with you all on that one James Kirk would kick Scotts ass. That and he's a way better vocalist.

 

[fuelee2004]

gay thread. Scott is the better vocalist by far.

Yep these 'who's better' threads are gay, and IMHO i think both James and Scott are awesome in their own way. Hard to compare the two especially when Charlie writes most the riffs!

 

[Stormwatch]

What's awesome about James Hetfield these days? Please explain his current "awesomeness" cos I don't see it. His songs are shit, his lyrics are shit, his vocals are shit, he cant even drink anymore FFS - what's awesome?