Top 50 Thrash Albums

[JayKeeley]

Anyone seen this list?

 

[Nico]

Uhg. Don't start this again.

 

[lurch70]

the list is good ... the order is shit.

 

[KILL TULLY]

Sick list, I just ignored the order anyways.

 

[Johanna]

wow I own a great big huge majority of those, does that mean I rule?
Good list, crappy order, more underground please

edit: says guess who

 

[Dark One]

Some excellent albums there, but not one Razor on the list? Come on.

 

[Nico]

Honestly, there were about 6 of us who made the list, and the votes were judged by average scores out of 100. A lot of great shit missed out, and a lot of rubbish made it on there. Averages are like that!

 

[Dark One]

You know, I honestly think these types of polls and lists would be more meaningful if bands were restricted to one album per list. (other classic releases by whatever band can be mentioned in the capsule write-ups if so desired).

 

[Nico]

I disagree. If nothing else, both Kill 'em All AND Ride the Lightning deserve a spot in a top 50.

 

[Dark One]

I disagree. If nothing else, both Kill 'em All AND Ride the Lightning deserve a spot in a top 50.

I don't disagree about those albums, I just feel it should be restricted to bands rather than all releases. Perhaps an even better idea would be to pick the band rather than an album and then explain why (In Metallica's case, KEA, RTL, MoP, etc.).

 

[Nico]

Next up we're doing a death metal list. Expect more disapointment

 

[Dark One]

LOL

 

[dorian gray]

looking forward to the death metal list

 

[spaffe]

Thrash is the genre I've spent least time with and of those fifty records I've heard three -- all Metallica Though if it wasn't for the Internetz I wouldn't care

 

[JayKeeley]

it's gay because it has megadeth at #2

yeah i agree, what's up with that? why wasn't it at #1???

Good fucking list IMO.

 

[skeptik]

rc should make a list

 

[JayKeeley]

dozen eggs
7 grain bread
orange juice (tropicana)
filet mignon
baking potatoes
sour cream
old english mustard

 

[jimbobhickville]

Meh, Forbidden #27? List should be named "50 best thrash albums for people who thought they heyday of thrash was before the musicians learned to play their instruments". But I guess that's the majority of metal fans, sadly

 

[lurch70]

dozen eggs
7 grain bread
orange juice (tropicana)
filet mignon
baking potatoes
sour cream
old english mustard

cashier: "you must be single"
customer: "why do you say that? is it the things I am buying?"
cashier: "no, it's because you're bloody ugly"

 

[JayKeeley]

lol <- for real