two mixes of one song %-) Need yor rate and suggestions $-) Alt.Metal with female voc

[CrazyClown]

here
www.deforceband.ru/song1.mp3
www.deforceband.ru/song2.mp3
two mixes of one song.
What your like more?
Guitar, bass tones, drums in which mix your like more?
have any suggestions at sound?

 

[CrazyClown]

A lot of posts 8-(

 

[Loren Littlejohn]

Well first off let me say that I just plain like the song. If I had to chose though it would be the 2nd one because it doesn't feel like it crushed as much.

However I am listening at the moment through $30 headphones at work so I don't feel my judgment is that accurate at the moment.

 

[CrazyClown]

Thanx The 1st has more maximazed at premastering ;-)

 

[Erkan]

I think both of them sound too limited and crushed

Cool music though, a more heavy version of Lacuna Coil

 

[CrazyClown]

Premastering is not my favourite job ;-)
Lacuna coil? interesting opinion

 

[Erik Monsonis]

1st one sounds more balanced to my ears, but there's still too much compression, listen to the cymbals from 00:52 they sound squashed and with 0 dynamics.
Guitar tone is good, i like it.
The music is really cool, you could do some processing on the vox, like dubbing, stereo panoramizing some phrases or so, it sounds way too centered.
BTW, what language is it?

Best regards.
-Erik