The problem is; you immediately dismiss it as a gimmick, without bothering to do any research on WHY you might want video at a gig. You just think its to cover up a shitty performance or shitty live show. Which is bullshit.
Nate really answered it perfectly; "But without the total stage pcakage of killer lights, killer video screens, KILLER CONTENT to display on the screens, it's not going to be something to augment your initial live show." In the context of "cheap", video is going to be an awfully cheesy thing to do/have.
Are Tool gimmicky, or are they creating an experience?
Gimmicky, pretentious, shitty... I really hate Tool though, so don't take it too personally
Now, I can imagine one aspect where video would be cool, and that is if you've got a concept album going on with the video illustrating the lyrics synced up to the music -- THAT would be awesome. But again, that's not going to be cheap, to do that well it'd be exorbitant.
I'm sorry.. but your attitude is very typical of this place; too concerned with having balls and bringing the br00talz to even stop to consider the artistry involved in metal and production.
The way I see it... there is mood and atmosphere... and then there is booze and shitty blast beats.
You obviously haven't really listened to my music :idk: I definitely understand the artistry involved in metal, and as a matter of fact my music is definitely more on the artistic side than the "br00talz/ballsy" side.
What are you talking about? I never said my band was the same level as Tool you stonehead. The trouble is... Parsons never said "get a solid performance first" ... he brushed off the idea of video as a gimmick.. and he did it with a very snide vibe behind his words.
My apologies if you took it as a snide remark -- it was just my advice and personal thought on the matter. Especially since you qualified it with cheap, and video is probably one of the more expensive things. And as a matter of fact, I'll go post some cheap ideas that may really help your stage show. Maybe we'll be even then
I think at the end of the day, for someone to just burst into a thread like he did and make a stupid comment
without any thought behind it.. it just brushed me up the wrong way. So I decided to do the same thing!
Why do you assume that? Truth be told, I actually did think about whether or not video would be a good idea given the sort of budget you specified, and decided it probably wouldn't be, at which point I made the recommendation I did.
Tool don't really have any stage presence. They let the music speak for itself; which imo, is the better approach. In my humble opinion, choreographing your moves in the practice room is... well... pretty weak.
...
I say: Let the vibe of the venue move you. Sink into the music, sink into the crowd.. follow their vibe... and it will be a much more rewarding experience for everyone.
I totally agree! Choreographing stage moves is pretty lame. But... who said I, or my band, does that? We do just like you said... let the music happen, get into it, and enjoy it. The crowd then follows. Trust me, if I were intent on choreographing our stage moves, we'd be all together a lot more often