Worst splintering of perfectly good band for lesser or no bands!

[TD]

I hate it when a band breaks up, and we either get two or more shitty bands, or no band at all. Which is the worst tragedy here, you be the judge:

 

[augdawg2]

Losing Rage was the worst for me! I wasn't real happy when Max left Sepultura at first either, but at least Sepultura still makes records. I actually really enjoyed "Against", but ofcourse, you can't beat "Arise", and "Beneath the Remains".

Cheerz!

AugDawg

 

[TD]

Each one of these scenarios sucked! I think I made it a tough decision. I noticed one person went for the Sabbath option - I made an error there btw, it was Ray Gillen not Ian, but at any rate, a lot of people probably don't remember just how bad of an album Black Sabbaths "Born Again" was - it was just horrible. The two Dio led albums before it were fantastic, but once Iommi shit canned Dio, Sabbath would suck for the rest of its existence. OK, they don't suck now, but they are hardly a band, they do nothing new, they just tour every other summer on Ozzfest.

 

[Steve M]

i think stereomud is pretty decent and i really like keith's solo stuff. and whit was still pretty kick ass even though he wasn't keith.

 

[KY_Fried442]

I voted for the Sepultura/Soulfly as being the worst. I never cared for Rage, never cared for Black Sabbath without Ozzy, and actually like Stereomud better then LOA.

 

[ThraxDude]

I think Sepultura and Soulfly are great bands.
Against and Primitive are killer albums. 2 of my favorites, anyway.

 

[Brentney Spears]

Sepultura's Roots was pure genius. Everything since then has been weak by both bands. Ozzy Sabbath is the only Sabbath. Never got into Rage or LOA. You can hear the rest of my opinions at the next boat show.

/BT

 

[Jono]

The thing is with Sabbath they were almost a completely different band when Dio replaced Ozzy and the same goes for when DIo left. Tony is a bitch.
Sepultura isn't AS good, but I didn't like roots anyway. And soulfly is ok.
the rest... whatever
-Jono-

 

[HotRodFlamedJJ2]

Originally posted by TD
but at any rate, a lot of people probably don't remember just how bad of an album Black Sabbaths "Born Again" was - it was just horrible.

I always liked "Zero the Hero". Pretty stupid lyrics, but the tune itself was good.

 

[TD]

"Zero the Hero" sounded good when Cannibal Corpse covered it!

 

[TD]

Originally posted by Brentney Spears
Sepultura's Roots was pure genius. Everything since then has been weak by both bands. Ozzy Sabbath is the only Sabbath. Never got into Rage or LOA. You can hear the rest of my opinions at the next boat show.

/BT

Popular opinion is that Ozzy Sabbath is the only Sabbath, but I would like anyone who says that to listen to the last two Sabbath records with Ozzy (Technical Ecstacy and Never Say Die ) and compare them to the two albums the elf did with Sabbath (Heaven and Hell and Mob Rules ) Sabbath with Ronnie James Dio is one of the most underrated metal bands ever, it's really shocking how people overlook this band.

 

[HotRodFlamedJJ2]

Originally posted by TD
"Zero the Hero" sounded good when Cannibal Corpse covered it!

I didn't know it had been covered. I thought of doing it myself. I'll have to check that out. Thanks.

 

[trapper]

you left out faith no more, and the break up of soundgarden, they would rank right up there. so i didnt vote

 

[nafnikufesin]

How about the breakdown of Metallica?

 

[mrthrax]

yeah it always sucks when bands break up,there are not to many bands out there that can lose a member(namely singer)and keep that special something that they had with there fans.

I was heaps nervous when i heard talk about phil leaving pantera but on the contrary the rumour of ripper owens from judas replacing him is sorta comforting!!!

 

[ImmortalCorruptor]

I heard on the radio yesterday that Rage and Cornell are back together.

 

[AjDeath]

Sep would have been one of the greatest thrash bands ever if they just stuck to the music, Kornfly, LOL I really hate that band and the new Sep.