Shit me, this was a toughie. In a tossup between "Caught...", "Heaven..." and "Alexander...", I chose the one that was running through my head at the time and it was Heaven Can Wait
Sea of Madness. It might not be *the* best song on the album, but it was one of the maiden songs that first caught my ear, so it gets the nostalgia vote.
being very fond of the album on a whole i cannot vote, i cant pick my fave album eather. however for a short space of time i was considering going for waisted years as that begining riff is amazing.