Basing it on multiple studio albums. I wouldn't pay to see these guys live (hell, I wouldn't even really want to see them for free). And do not tell me that "if only you gave them a chance live" or something along those lines. I'd give that chance to something that sounded like it had at least some chance live, but these guys do not.
Nothing special with this band at all (except most of their fanbase, and in that case I'd use 'special' differently. And no, I'm not talking about anyone here).
To me, this is another band that jumped on the emo/metal bandwagon a few years ago and I'm sure they plan on riding it out until it's no longer cool to do.