Clash of the Thrash round 4 Kill em all v Rust in peace

[Dän]

Kill em all easy. Rust has some good songs, but is no where near as consistant as kill. If rust was full of good songs then it would get my vote, but it doesnt so it wont

 

[RavenHasFlownAway]

Rust in Peace - More Interesting

Anaesthesia is a real non filler track :S

You suck Doug

 

[RavenHasFlownAway]

Well Dave wrote Kill em all, and evolved as a better writter from there... Rust in Peace is Deths best work, and Deth is better than tallica so Rust In Peace wins/

Marty Friedman > Kirk Hammet

Difference being Metallica didnt need random line up changes with hot shot guitarists to keep people interested.......

Dave was a better writer when he didnt know what the fuck he was doing

 

[RavenHasFlownAway]

I don't like Kill 'Em All at all really. I own all Metallica albums and I just don't like it, especially compared to their other albums. The only Metallica album it beats is St. Anger.

MEGADETH RUST IN PEACE FTW!

Respect level has just plummeted............

 

[cro4eva]

Difference being Metallica didnt need random line up changes with hot shot guitarists to keep people interested.......

Dave was a better writer when he didnt know what the fuck he was doing

It may of done Metallica some good if they followed in Daves footsteps.

 

[RavenHasFlownAway]

It may of done Metallica some good if they followed in Daves footsteps.

I dont think even Metallica would re-record one of there songs and get Christina Scabbia to sing on it ..........

 

[FerretallicA]

I don't think Megadeth would record something like "St Anger" to begin with.

 

[RavenHasFlownAway]

I don't think Megadeth would record something like "St Anger" to begin with.

Risk anyone?

 

[FerretallicA]

Risk is a fucking good album.
Easily better than anything Immortal ever put out.

 

[RavenHasFlownAway]

Risk is a fucking good album.
Easily better than anything Immortal ever put out.

I hate you

 

[in_absentia]

you hate alot of people

 

[FerretallicA]

A lot of people deserve it.

 

[Dän]

Why the hell is Rust winning?

It's really not that good; plus Kill came out like 7 yrs earlier so its a distorted poll; either way Kill > every megadeth album combined.

 

[Watto]

Wow Rust in Piece is killing it, I should of went with puppets. I see the heated MetallicA vs Megedeth arguments have come out. Now to add some feul to the fire hehehe Metallica is the most metal band on the planet they have proven that with St Anger. Megadeth sucks and they can't play guitar or write songs for shit. *sits with evil grin and waits hahaha*

 

[RavenHasFlownAway]

Megadeth have 4 decent songs . 3 of them are on Rust In Peace.........

So i guess its there best album.

 

[FerretallicA]

Even if your gross underestimate were at all accurate, that would still be 4 more decent songs than Immortal have.

 

[RavenHasFlownAway]

Even if your gross underestimate were at all accurate, that would still be 4 more decent songs than Immortal have.

Valid points made by Ferret equal Zero

 

[RavenHasFlownAway]

Risk is a fucking good album.
Easily better than anything Immortal ever put out.

Make that minus 1

 

[Aussie_Metalchild]

Risk anyone?

I would listen to Risk any day over that steaming pile of shit that was St Anger.

I love old Metallica but in the end...

Megadeth > Metallica

too easy.

 

[RavenHasFlownAway]

Megadeth > Metallica

You lose