Let's see.............
One one hand we have a psycho cross-eyed midgett who is boring as fuck on stage, has a greater passion for watches then guitar, and seems to have lost his grip on reality almost completely.
On the other hand, we have a seemingly gay, passive, seel-out who seems to think that the wah wah peddle is more important then the guitar he is actually playing.
They both recieve the Thrillho D-
Both amazing guys in their day - but I lost all respect for kirk. Mainly because he chooses to stay in Metallica. The BIGGEST sell-out band ever. A band that tells him "We are not going to have lead guitar on this record" and he LETS THEM have their way. It's bad enough he has not played a good lead in years, but now they have taken away his use in the band, and he continues to stick it out. It's not like he needs the money.
Spitz, what can I say, the man scares me. Straight up. I love all the work he did with Anthrax, but let's face it - it is hard to compare these two. We have not heard a new lead out of Spitz since SOWN. I mean, we know Kirk continued to decline - maybe Spitz still has some aces up his sleave, we won't know for a while if we ever do get to find out.
So yeah I pick Dimebag.