Dark Side or the Wall?

[Ocelot2010]

Which would you pick if somebody pointed a deadly weapon to your head and told you to "pick or die?"

Personally I have to say the Wall


NOTHING beats Comfortably Numb, the Trial, all three parts to Another Brick in the Wall, Young Lust, Mother, Empty Spaces, Goodbye Blue Sky

In comparison, what does Dark Side have? Time and Breathe

 

[Never the same]

The Wall is great but.. if you've seen Dark Side live you'll change thoughts. Goddamn fantastic album. The only album which runs so smoothly you never knew the next track started or ended.

And.. Wish you were here pwns this thread. Best album ever.

 

[Lordmoron]

The Wall is the greatest Pink Floyd album imo, it fuckin awesome although Darkside and Wish You Were Here are both excellent

 

[D.Ingram]

Darkside of the Moon, but only just. The Wall has Comfortably Numb after all, but DSOTM is just.... incredible.

 

[Keenan]

The Wall is great but.. if you've seen Dark Side live you'll change thoughts. Goddamn fantastic album. The only album which runs so smoothly you never knew the next track started or ended.

And.. Wish you were here pwns this thread. Best album ever.

Why must you constantly read my mind?!?!

Wish You Were Here beats all else.... But to contribute to the topic.... Dark Side.

 

[Ocelot2010]

Maybe it's because I can relate to some of the stuff that happens to Pink in the Wall that makes me love it so much.

 

[Slatanictrash]

Going through a Final Cut phase

Just loving this album

I am not big on the wall, I love comfortably numb but the rest of the album doesn't do it for me

I would even rate Meddles higher than the Wall

 

[D.Ingram]

Meddle is a good record but The Wall is better - Meddle was when they just managed to fid thir feet a bit.