Fanboy thread alert!! 12 or Black Erotica?

[Lethe78]

Well?

 

[Katatonic89]

I voted for 12, Jonas growls are nothing compared to Mikaels. But I like the intro to Black Erotica, they should have recorded it for 12 aswell.

 

[Nightmare_Heaven]

Thats a hard question, I'll have to think about it. they may be the same song but they're both so different as versions that each one stands alone quite well.

 

[BlueSky]

I went with For My Demons ...

 

[Lethe78]

I voted for 12, Jonas growls are nothing compared to Mikaels. But I like the intro to Black Erotica, they should have recorded it for 12 aswell.

I voted for BE. The intro is awesome, and the whole song has a darker feel to it IMO.

 

[cliffburton615]

Black Erotica, the intro just builds up brilliantly into the song. Has a great atmosphere to it.

 

[Lethe78]

They are tuned differently also.. 12 is Dropped "D"... not sure what Black Erotica is. Maybe Standard.

 

[Niurus]

12 is half step down. So it's D#, not D. And could someone tell me, Black Erotica is in the compilation album "Brave Yester Days", right? If it's a compilation album, in which album is the original track? It just wasn't released or what?

 

[Nightmare_Heaven]

12 is half step down. So it's D#, not D. And could someone tell me, Black Erotica is in the compilation album "Brave Yester Days", right? If it's a compilation album, in which album is the original track? It just wasn't released or what?

It was originally on a various artists compilation in the 90s (W.A.R. I think) along with another track...."Love of the Swan"...both sound like they were recorded in 93/94 era, either leftovers or for a projected follow up to DODS or FFTC.

 

[Lethe78]

12 is half step down. So it's D#, not D. And could someone tell me, Black Erotica is in the compilation album "Brave Yester Days", right? If it's a compilation album, in which album is the original track? It just wasn't released or what?

Ya... I'm playing it now and it is in D#. I play it on my Dropped D guitar... I guess I should learn how to play it on my D# guitar.....