"I" arrived today -- listening to it now, Scarred For Life is brilliant of course (had it on MP3 for ages), but now I get to discover the rest of the album
Oh wow! You started with Nightingale in the exact same place I did. "I" is still my favorite over-all album by NG. "I Return" is the real knock-out punch on that album for me.
Excellent album. Scarred For Life was also one of the first songs of theirs I heard (after Dreamreader and Nightfall Overture). My favorites from it are Drowning In Sadness, Remorse And Regret, and The Game.