I have a soft spot in my heart for Gamma Ray. They slayed at PPUSA III.
Land of the Free II, the latest from Kai and company, is pretty darn good. I don't think the production is bad at all. At a low volume, it isn't as crisp as I like my CDs to be. But crank it up and it rings out loud and proud. The songs are upbeat, fun to listen to, and air-guitar friendly. I'm sure they'll be a blast to see performed live.
Production-wise, I think Helloween's latest, Gambling With the Devil, is no better than Land of the Free II. Singer Andi Deris reminds me of Halford when he hits those piercing notes. But I prefer Kai's voice. And the songs on Gambling aren't grabbing me as quickly as those on Land.
Listening to these CDs back to back borders on German power-metal overload. They're so similar in style that it's hard to tell them apart.
I think I have to give the nod to Gamma Ray, though. I find myself returning to Gamma Ray more often than Helloween.
But, you know what? We can't lose. Seeing both of these bands on stage in the same night is going to be an unforgettable experience!