yes, and i've retracked drums before. didnt tell them... drums were not tracked to a grid, and they were unusable. it was 100% sample replaced though so they didnt know haha. actually played the kick parts on my snare
if the bass player struggles for over 5 minutes, i automatically whip out the big stick and tell the guitarist to record the bass, giving him a 30 second lesson on how to play bass well.
Was trying to find the poster Joe Barresi has in his studio. Yes it happens, a lot. Mostly with Bass players, unfortunately for me being a bass player makes it that much worse watching them fail.
Haha, just picked my basses up from Schecter so I can re track bass for this bands EP. I totally won't feel bad in the morning either after I track it, because this band was solid. Too solid to be let down by a weak bass player with an even worse sounding bass.
I had did such a lot of mistakes tracking the guitars (the tone was absolutely crap) that I felt guilty. I retracked guitars : no waste of time for the band ! It was a kind of imitation game for me. Difficult but cool in the end.