I am so dead serious

[TheNewChupe]

ok but I'm sure that without GTA there wouldn't have ever been a Vice City but who is going to argue that GTA was a better game?

just sayin in my book groundbreaking innovation is worth more points than taking what's been done and doing it kind of differently (albeit good- i was a gnr fan too)

 

[minxnim]

annyway josh i understand you're caught up in the heat of the moment of a much loved gnr song but let's not do anything rash here you know?

 

[TheNewChupe]

i said zeppelin!
christ!

yep, that's where i got it from. it was a good point.

 

[Josh Seipp]

I missed that one! ok out of everyone you all mentioned I would accept zep and the stones as worth arguing.

 

[Josh Seipp]

annyway josh i understand you're caught up in the heat of the moment of a much loved gnr song but let's not do anything rash here you know?

13 year moment!

 

[lizard]

GNR at their brief peak had it all, the attitude, the balls, the heroin...

the Beatles did more to advance the recording of popular music than anyone, c'mon, from mono for chrisakes...to using the studio as a palette...(sp)

 

[xfer]

i think you have a definite point that zeppelin may be a better rock band than GNR. (sorry josh). MAYBE.

 

[deadair]

...i said ratt

 

[minxnim]

also, pink floyd i mean COME ON! dude i swear we need to erase this thread b/c eric clapton might show up and try to beat you up and i'd hate for that to happen =[

 

[minxnim]

i also think aerosmith, in their heyday, were better than gnr (in the dream on days) and i also think that kiss were (i wanna rock n roll all night!!!!) .
you also have to realize, i really really LIKE gnr and have all their albums.

 

[avi]

black sabbath is my most favorite band ever. step off.

 

[xfer]

 

[xfer]

notice no one took exception to her mention of black sabbath, except to wonder if they were rock n roll.

 

[minxnim]

gnr i mean... they wouldnt even know what buttons to push or what happens when you push them if they couldn't walk in the footsteps of most of these people. not to say in the slightest that this means they suck at all, but they're not BETTER i mean sayin. i think even axl would admit the beatles are better than him. unless he's too busy getting all fat still.

 

[Josh Seipp]

dudes I like black sabbath MORE than GNR

this thread STAYS! Eric Clapton wouldn't know rock and roll if he slipped and landed in a vat of it!

Alex no need to apologize. I definitley think that you could argue that zeppelin were more rock n roll. anyway we're all friends here.

 

[TheNewChupe]

you know, what i find annoying is that if a single guy from one of the huge bands like John Paul Jones does a tour, like 30 people show up but if that big huge name (like THE STONES) does a tour, it's the BIGGEST THING ON EARTH, sponsored by Miller, Pepsi, Best Buy, and McDonalds and all these dorks come out of the woodwork to relive their pitiful youth. big money sucks.

 

[Josh Seipp]

I think the beatles were too hippy to be in the running (not that there's anything WRONG with that). I mean, how many hotel rooms did they destroy?

 

[xfer]

well we wouldn't be listening to this fucking RAWK at all if some caveman hadn't picked up a hollow reed and tooted out the proto-notes for "hot cross buns" on it, would we? earlier does not necessarily mean MORE ROCKINER.

 

[TheNewChupe]

...i said ratt

jake, my freshman yr roommate would've agreed.
and he was also FROM IOWA. coincidence? or is it something in the corn?

 

[deadair]

big money does suck eric... fight the man... DAMN THE MAN