OK, here we go.
01. Sounds of a Playground Fading 7.5/10
Nice clean intro with Metallica feel. Crunchy modern riff, epic chorus and catchy little solo. Solid song, if a bit predictable (structure). All in all, good opener, but nothing groundbreaking.
02. Deliver Us 7/10
Compact hit. Melodic and straightforward, also very modern sounding. Interesting vocal melodies. Solo is good, but again a bit predictable (cry-cry-speed-cry-cry-speed-melody-harmonized melody). Very catchy chorus. Song sounds like it was written to be single. (hehe, sellouts)
03. All for Me 6.5/10
Fantastic clean intro in 3/4 time signature that really screams: IN FLAMES! Unfortunately, song doesn't seem to have much connection with intro. Heavy riffs, but nothing stands out. Nice melodic parts towards the end, but that's it. I was expecting more from this one.
04. The Puzzle 10/10
Now this is one mean fucker! Fast rhythms, wicked vocal melodies and one of the best IF choruses ever. Middle part with solo breaks the song nicely, making stuff more interesting. Great atmospheric keys and guitars towards the end.
05. Fear is the Weakness 9/10
Starts with gentle clean guitars and then comes keyboard dominated intro (a bit of Soilwork and Solution .45 in this). Great verses and lyrics. I really like little solos and leads Bjorn did through out the song. Very tastefully done. Chorus is good, but there are some better on this album. Also, notice that cool melody from studio episode 2 (I think) that's in the background of the chorus. This song has more positive feeling than All for me, The Puzzle and SOAPF.
06. Where Dead Ships Dwell 8/10
Sounds better on CD than live. Nice samples and fantastic trademark In Flames riffs. Some great electronic/ambiental stuff before and with chorus. One of highlights of the album - sweet dual guitar lead at the end of the solo.
07. The Attic 9/10
Weird experimental stuff with bluesy guitar and some samples in the background. Very dark, moody, melancholic piece of music. I like it. Feels so personal.
08. Darker Times 7/10
I had a feeling this one will be standard issue In Flames filler song...and I was not far from truth. Modern generic riffing, almost techno drumming and infamous "I have a better plan, I have a better plan". Good stuff: vocals at 1:38, phenomenal chorus, and solid (but not really original) solos.
09. Ropes 8/10
Great intro riff/melody. Really powerful and catchy. Anders cleans are so good in this one. Again one good solo from Bjorn. Song has a positive feeling, it is very easy to consume and I have no doubts it will be very popular.
10. Enter Tragedy 8/10
Aggressive side of SOAPF. Brutal riffing and great chorus. Interesting breakdown and quite unexpected solo.
11. The Jester's Door 10/10
Weird sounds, spooky sounds, accordion (!?), spoken part, ambient stuff, electro beats, original sounding keys... Is this soundtrack of some awesome game? No, still an In Flames song...and a damn good one. Thumbs up for originality.
12. A New Dawn 10/10
Trademark In Flames riffs and melodies, great verses, great chorus, Anders inspired, gentle clean guitar stuff, cellos and violins + good songwriting = great fucking song. I love this one.
13. Liberation 8/10
While a bit gay...this song is not that bad. I don't really like that radio rock chords at the begging of the chorus (btw every emo girl in the crowd will sing along). Solo - Bjorn goes Rockstar/Guitarhero! Song ends with long, calm, prog rock part. I really like they gave up the 3 minute nu-metal songs in favor of more mature songwriting. (Now, many of you will wonder why did I rate this one with 8 and SOAPF with 7.5... SOAPF is a good song, but this one is exploring some new ground for IF, and will be more interesting in a year or two then a more standard sounding SOAPF)
All together this gives us... 8.3 if I'm not mistaken. Not bad at all. Beats LS, RTR, STYE, CC and ASOP in my book. It was a long time since I was this excited by IF album. All band members did their job fantastically. A lot of credit should be given to keyboard guy.
Oh, yeah, about production... Guitars are not so distorted but they have incredible clarity (as Bjorn said in studio episode). Bass is really deep and there are moments when it comes from the background and add a few nice touches to some songs. Vocals are done great (you really need to be an expert to do this stuff). Keys and samples are just incredible, and I wouldn't mind if they did some bonus tracks that are all electronic. So all instruments are good, but drums are BEST! This must be greatest drum sound ever.