Love of the Swan / Questions about DoDS

doom_dragon

dead soul
Jun 27, 2002
112
0
16
I just heard "Love of the Swan". This part from 3:03 to 3:33 is one of the best melodic moments in Katatonia history (imho). Only 30 seconds, but it's awesome. My questions now are:

1.) What's about the second WAR Compilation track "Black Erotica"? I heard, that it's only another version of "12". What is the difference?

2.) Were they recorded together with "Dance of December souls" or at this time?

3.) Was it Jonas who did the growls?

4.) I began listening to Katatonia with "For Funerals to come" and BMD, but I still didn't get the chance for laying my hands on DoDS. Can anyone give me a review?

5.) Is it a MUST HAVE?
 
Hi!

1. Haven't a clue actually.
2. As far as I know the track was recorded before they recorded Dance of December Souls
3. On DoDS he did the growls, I haven't heard Black Erotica in a while and can't really remember if he did the vocals or not...
4. The album as a whole is great. Keyboards play a bigger role than on For funerals to come and Brave Murder Day, which sometimes almost sound happy. Jonas his vocals are as intense as ever. I'll just copy and paste a good review. Here goes:
Production: Reasonable but airy, holds well the flowing emulsified flesh of keyboards and space rock guitars.
Review: This band are aesthetic masters; they have cleanly meshed a dark black metal style into a keyboarded stadium heavy metal style with gothic and atmospheric rock influences, making something which sounds good while bearing a black-ish aesthetic, all while being essentially a rock band creating personal delusions of emotional grandeur. Yet instrumentation is precise, and rock theory has been expanded for creativity in delivering the dynamic shape of atmosphere across a range of phrases, giving nods to the classics of black metal and their power in breaking musical ideas into melody.

These riffs have been heard before, with one being the same general pattern as "Dead Skin Mask" from Slayer and another being reminiscent of Dismember, the fourth track on Katatonia borrowing roughly from the first album of those Swedish gods (Override of the Overtures). Another aesthetic foundation: Cemetary, from whom some of the keyboard integration technique is borrowed. Other "Visible Influences and Derivations" include a real desire to be My Dying Bride, andsome elements of the more melodic older metal; Iron Maiden lurks in the appeal to grand gestures and symbolism especially in the choice of harmonies on which to base melodic work. If one listens carefully to track six one of the simpler At the Gates riffs makes an appearance, denoting another influence, most prominently in the treatment of continuity in melodic phrasing.



Tracklist:
1. Seven Dream Souls (Intro)
2. Gateways of Bereavement
3. In silence Enshrined
4. Without god
5. Elohim Meth
6. Velvet Thorns (of Drynwhyl)
7. Tomb of Insomnia
8. Dancing December
Length: 53:50


The previous EP from this band was more of an atmospheric endeavor than this, and seems distinctive from a comparative listen. "Dance of December Souls" is a rehash symphony, and lacks the epic quality that first rate black metal does, yet for rock-based music with the aesthetic of black metal and the emotions of a mainstream band, it is an enjoyable frivolous listen if you can live past the predictable parts. Of those, there is little to fear: the semi-waltz beats of mainstream black metal mixed with atomspheric rock bridges and choruses, raining sentiment from their maudlin and moribund discourse. Yet intrinsically this is self-centered teen isolationist angst music, and for that describes its existential desires well.

Harsh black metal vocals over dark guitar, with clean guitar picked carefully in the background, and layers of keyboard washing through the whole. This has heavier, more decisive percussion than the EP, and is a welcome change in that area, but seems to be more enmired in the current ideas of metal as commercial vehicle than what the EP targetted. Where the "melodic metal" movement brings heavy metal and goth into metal, there are few successes, but for sheer musicality and mastery of aesthetic this band dominates them, while understandably not finding the influential minds of the underground impressed.
5. It is if you liked BMD and FFTC.

Greetz
 
1.) Black Erotica is the same song but much better than "12". Better over all sound and especially Jonas singing is much better than what Mikael from Opeth does.

2.) No, later. They are recorded 17-18 June 1994.

3.) Yes.

5.) YES!
 
duga said:
1.) Black Erotica is the same song but much better than "12". Better over all sound and especially Jonas singing is much better than what Mikael from Opeth does.
I think Blakkheim might be singing on BE, instead of Renkse.
 
Ormir said:
I think Blakkheim might be singing on BE, instead of Renkse.

The W.A.R. Compilation booklet says:

Blackheim - electric rhythm/lead guitars, acoustic guitars/keyboards
Israphel - bass
Lord J. Renkse - drums/vocals