Mix comparison, which do you like better?

[nwright]

OK, here's 2 mixes of 2 songs done by 2 different people. Same exact tracks given to each person

It's a somewhat bad comparison, as I have the mp3 for one and the Myspace for the other, but interested in what you glean from each mix.

Which one sounds better overall to you guys?

The songs are One Day Closer and Loaded Pistol, so you may have to select to play each one off Myspace.

http://www.myspace.com/beyondagony

http://geetarguy.tripod.com/onedaycloser.mp3

http://geetarguy.tripod.com/LoadedPistol.mp3

 

[ExDown]

OK, here's 2 mixes of 2 songs done by 2 different people. Same exact tracks given to each person

It's a somewhat bad comparison, as I have the mp3 for one and the Myspace for the other, but interested in what you glean from each mix.

Which one sounds better overall to you guys?

The songs are One Day Closer and Loaded Pistol, so you may have to select to play each one off Myspace.

http://www.myspace.com/beyondagony

http://geetarguy.tripod.com/onedaycloser.mp3

http://geetarguy.tripod.com/LoadedPistol.mp3

LoadedPistol.mp3 sounds by far the best! Guitars are closer in the mix, everything sounds better actually. Good job!

 

[Sinister Mephisto]

Basically useless unless they're on the same format. Since you don't have the mp3 for the other guys mix, why don't you upload yours to myspace so we can compare the Myspace version of the mixes?