Obituary - Xecutioner's Return

Death Aflame

voice of dissent
Feb 1, 2004
2,504
2
38
38
Obituary - Xecutioner's Return
Candlelight - August 28, 2007
By Jordan Knoll

200px-Xecutioners_return_cover_V5.jpg


It really cannot be argued against that death metal as a whole peaked in the early 90s. So many classic releases in such a short span of time across many diverse scenes—Florida, Sweden, Finland and to a lesser extent New York—all with their own unique sounds. This is anything but the case today as anyone who is fan of that era knows well enough that the contemporary death metal scene is far from matching the early scene’s impressive prowess and unrelenting originality. It just so happens that Florida’s Obituary are one of the few remaining acts from that glorified epoch long since passed who still happen to be churning out death metal in the style of the early days of the genre. This brings us to their latest release aptly entitled Xecutioner’s Return.

I am pleased to report that Obituary seem to have found a way to compose competent, evil sounding death metal encased within a thick, crushing production that allows the music to breathe organically and burrow into the mind ruthlessly; no small feat for a band who has been active for almost eighteen years. In turn, this production approach gives the aura of the music a distinct and highly potent atmosphere that was so integral to the genre in its early years and is all but absent today. For instance, the deceptively groove laden ‘Evil Ways’ manages to articulate its brooding atmosphere, while utilizing a slow almost half-thrash approach to the riffing without sounding out of place or cheesy in any manner. While most of the album seems to rest itself somewhere in that mid-paced range (for death metal) it is always pleasing to hear contrasts between pace, especially when the riffs therein are written as well as they are here. Don’t get me wrong, this isn’t an Asphyx album, but the occaisional pace-based contrast gives the album its ‘listenability’ and rewarding depth for future spins.

All is not well for Xecutioner’s Return, however. While the band manages to nail the production and generally succeeds in the compositional sphere the infrequent forays into shredding often detract from the music more than adds to it. For example, ‘Drop Dead’ is nearly suffocated beneath a barrage of finger-stretching guitar wankery, which is shame when the majority of the song contains good riffs. Fortunately this is a relatively minor quibble amongst a sea of good, dark dirty death metal. Xecutioner’s Return may not blow your mind, but it certainly succeeds within the confines of its well worn mechanics. Recommended to fans of the early scene, and those who think death metal begins and ends with Job for a Cowboy.

Official Obituary Webpage
Official Candlelight Webpage
 
One of the best albums released by an oldschool band this year. Crushing and brutal! Don't really understand the "fret wankery" comment, as a band that has the talent of Ralph Santolla should utilize it! The Job for a Cowboy reference also had me puzzled.

If a plug is allowed, check out my recent interview with Donald Tardy in the Interview section at Wormwood:

http://www.wormwoodchronicles.com
 
The fret wankery comment was simply me indicating my distaste for the extensive (usually) atonal lead work that really adds nothing to the music on Xecutioner's Return. Some of it fits when it is not simply solo after solo laid over top riffs but most of it is not to my taste. That is all I was getting at.

Regarding the JfaC reference, I was simply trying to influence the crowd that that rubbish death metal band draws (ties into my whole rant about the old death metal scene as compared to today's at the beginning of the review)to check out Obituary for some quality death metal by a band who knows how to compose as such. I may remove that reference if it continues to confound readers, however.
 
Can I make a suggestion. Would it be possible to link the band's myspace to the review. In fact I think that should be standard practice. It lets, we the readers, go straight to the music.