Copying and pasting my review of DHIADW from
Encylopaedia Metallum:
Doesn't live up to the previous two, but not bad - 76%
Written by Pyrus on June 2nd, 2003
Well, this is no
Dreaming Neon Black, that's for sure; then again, it would be extremely hard for any band to match the levels of mastery on that album.
Dead Heart instead goes in a new (dare I say "nu?" Nah...) direction, introducing a seven-string guitar and some more chugging, modern-ish riffs than the power/thrash of the previous effort. However, the ripping thrash of
Politics of Ecstacy remains very clearly evident, and come out sounding somewhat like Machine Head before they began to suck (i.e., the first album), only faster.
The album has a fairly unconvincing start, unfortunately, with "Narcosynthesis" kicking things off in undistinguished fashion. The main riff is pretty lame, the vocals are a bit too "nu"-sounding, and stealing the opening lines from "Devil's Child" didn't help. "We Disintegrate" is a solid song that would be much better if not for the pseudo-Middle Eastern wankery that bogs down the end of the song; the chorus is great however. "Inside Four Walls" is a live favorite, but sounds a bit too much like a couple of the suckier tracks on Judas Priest's
Demolition (even though this came first) for me to be comfortable with it. Things pick up quickly with the pulsing "Evolution 169," however.
That leads to the album's top spot, "The River Dragon Has Come," where the modern start-stop riffs work because Warrel Dane carries the song's melody, and carries it well. His voice still carries that "straining-to-hit-every-note" quality, probably a result of fucking up his throat doing Rob Halford impersonations on Sanctuary's first album, but he's technically flawless and full of emotion. "River Dragon" is also notable for Jeff Loomis's brilliant guitar work, especially on the dramatic sweep scales preceding the real solo.
From there, the album roars along in good fashion, featuring a really good ballad in "The Heart Collector" and a couple decent ones in "Insignificant" and "Believe In Nothing," the vicious attack of "Engines of Hate" and the rumbling thrash of the title track, and a sledgehammer-pounding, intricate cover of "The Sound of Silence," which shares nothing in common with the original but a short intro and the lyrics.
Speaking of lyrics, this continues the fine Nevermore tradition of some of the best lyrics in heavy metal, most notably "Engines of Hate" - "Sit back, enjoy the words, and feast on my mind's semen" and "Will you watch the hate machines spit evil/Or will you walk away and plead apathy again?" being two examples. The drumming is also stellar, especially on the nearly non-stop cymbal-and-bass barrage of the title track. All four members of Nevermore are incredibly talented musicians; they just need to get their riff-writing back up to par.
So overall, a solid album; just not up to the standards of the previous two. A bit too experimental in places, and the ballads, while good songs, just slow down the attack of the faster tracks. From what I've heard, the upcoming
Enemies of Reality seems to have no such compunctions about beating the shit out of its listeners...until that comes out, this is a good release to tide yourself over with.