Please Help deciding between to different mix approaches

[pitoga]

Greetings!!!

I've been messing with this song for quite a while now, and have come up with two different approaches in mixing it, the first one was the first version, in which i like the fact that it has more "air" to it everything is not too glued together, but then i think it is maybe too "airy". The second version Is louder (RMS) and i mixed the bass in a totally different way (this time using "MEl gibson's" haha tutorial as reference). I think it is more glued together and more punchy but maybe a bit to "smeared".

Please Help deciding which approach of both is the best, and in which way to improve it.

Thanks

First Version
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/3530360/Aevum/Human v1.c fixed.mp3

-----------------------
Second Version

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/3530360/Aevum/Human ultima tonta.mp3

 

[Seth Munson]

2nd one for meh

 

[slo77y]

second here ,too. try to go for the low end from the second mix and the high mids and top end from the first mix, that should turn out as a better mix than both of em.

 

[pitoga]

No one else? I don't know why lately when i post something to get critics or suggestions, not much users answer. A couple of month back this wasn't this way. hmmm I just want some input on guys that probably have a more trained ear or a better setup to notice things i didn't and even maybe have a possible solution to this, or advice.

Thanks