I still remember hearing those 'reroute to remain' leaked tracks and seeing pictures of them in these white jumpsuits and being like "Oh...fuck me"...but as much as I wish that I could personally change part of their current direction, they still do rock in a different way. The records (minus Reroute) aren't as solid and quality as the Clayman and back, and definitely not as strong or metal, but they have their own moments that are really good.
One of the worst tracks of their career "The chosen pessimist" has turned out to be one of my favorites on the newest record. It's like a post rock song turned into melodic deep metal. It's got a good emotion to it.
But in pure honesty...if they really went back to their metal roots and put out a real metal record like they used to do, even if it's for a 'break' or 'change' from their current identity, I'd be the first one stoked. I don't mean some half assed mnemic, fear factory worship Soilwork is calling "their roots" nowadays...we're talking the whole 9 yards.
It's like what Machine Head did in 2003 when they recorded 'through the ashes of empires'...there was still alot of nu metal, experimental 'Supercharger'ness to the record, but it was obvious they reawoke to real actual metal riffing again. Like thrash metal, not korn.