Really? Thanks guys. I thought it sounded a bit honky myself, but I seriously spent maybe 5 minutes on the guitars. I have DIs for the whole album and am going to reamp everything at once one weekend when I make the final tone decisions.
The chain there was Schecter Blackjack w/EMGs, Maxon OD820, Peavey 6505+, Mesa Recto Cab w/ V30s, SM57, stock RME Fireface preamp, Nuendo. Quad tracked (2 lead channel, 2 rhythm channel--thanks, Shane) and post EQd a little (thanks, Colin).
I definitely have to fiddle with the low end on the kicks...the sub in my truck was pounding a bit too much. Trying to judge low end in a small room sucks.