I don't mind how Gojira repeats riffs a lot, or play them longer than what everyone else considers typical... because the riffs are fucking heavy, awesome, and good. I'll admit that a lot of their stuff sounds like their influences, but they put it all together perfectly and throw their own atmospheric element on top of it.
They don't just groove out all the time though either. They actually get pretty technical in a lot of the parts on a lot songs, but they don't overdo it to the point of "Hey look at what we can do!!" They groove nice and good, and then they throw in a quick brain fuck to keep you thinking, and here and there they'll go down the tech path as for as long as they groove out sometimes. I dunno, it's kind of the perfect musical combination of everything I like about metal. I love super heavy pummeling riffs with lots of fast double bass, and I love the quirky tricks they throw in randomly that confuse me.
The drummer is the best part of the band. I absolutely love the way that guy plays. Some might call it "stop and go" bullshit, but I think about what the drummer is doing and it's really cool how they put those kind of things together. To me, they sound like a big huge fucking freight train that can stop and go at will, and you never ever ever know when it's coming.
Gojira encompasses every single element I appreciate in metal, right down to the lyrics and their take on the world. It's this combination of everything that makes them one of my all time favorites. I can understand how people lump them in genres and compare them other things they don't like. That's human nature. I'm just glad I'm able to see past it to how great this band really is.
Stefan, listen to this song. It's from their second album and not on their MySpace player. This song really shows their quirky heaviness. The part from about 1:38 - 2:45 or so clearly defines what makes this band so great to me. They don't warn you before they change riffs, and even though they might repeat the general idea of the riff, they're always doing something different, especially the drummer. Also from 4:00 onwards = epic epic epic. Tell me it wouldn't be fucking fun as shit to be that drummer!
And just for good measure... my current favorite Gojira song. This one grooves a bit more, but I still think it's a pretty unique song, and the last half is also super epic.
See the dude that comes on stage with the Gojira banner towards the end? That'll be me if they ever play this song when I see them live.
I fucking <3 Gojira.