Why would an American love any of the Premier League teams? The way the jersey looks on them?
I follow it loosely, but I don't have a favorite team. I live in the U.S., so most people who seem to have a favorite team overseas has to do either with the name, the jersey, or how often they are winning when they get into the sport. Whatever. I'd rather just watch talented people play the game, and follow certain players/teams, instead of getting into a superficial level of fandom. That said sometimes I, unjustly, cheer against certain teams because of certain players or coach's attitude (when the rest of the team might be perfectly fine).
p.s. I think there are legit reasons to be a fan of a team. For example, you might be the fan of the ownerships philosophy. Or a long time coach there's approach to the game or something like that.
I totally understand your point, and there's plenty of validity in it. I will offer my two cents on it though.
I was born in Brazil and as you can imagine, soccer is my favorite sport in the world. I've been into soccer since I can remember, and consider myself extremely passionate about it. Call it a soccer enthusiast if you want.
I can tell you that where I come from, soccer is bigger than pretty much everything else. When they say soccer is bigger than religion in Brazil, you bet your ass it's true (and Brazil is the country with the biggest catholic population in the world)! The love people develop for their favorite teams goes beyond any type of fandom for any other sports teams I've ever seen in America. For instance, let's use the Yankees as an example. They're the team with the biggest support in North America as far as I know, and when compared to the soccer fans down in Brazil, they look like a high school team. It's that big of a difference.
One more thing you have to keep in mind is that Brazilians are naturally good at soccer. It's the place in the world where you will find the most talented players. Just look at history, and you'll be able to see that. Needless to say, Brazil has won more World Cups than any other country in history.
I can't speak on behalf of Americans who're soccer fans. However, any true soccer fan who understands the game, will agree that the MLS SUCKS. The level of quality of the players and the teams, is very poor. Sometimes it's just plain ugly and boring watching some of these games, because they're just that bad! There are no relevant stars in the MLS (aside from the Beckham marketing move), the crowds seem to not give a shit, and there's no publicity at all. It's just a waste of time, really (in my opinion, at least). Therefore I understand why people here sometimes become true supporters of teams in Europe, afterall, there's not really a team that's worth the love true soccer fans develop for their teams.
I don't mean to offend anyone here, maybe I'm just used to a much higher level of soccer leagues, teams, matches, players... I just really want to understand why some people "love" the MLS and become "such avid fans" simply because it's the American league. It's like people know it's bad, but they'll get under the "It's American, so therefore it's good" mentality.
Would anybody else be able to give their opinion on Cheiron's question? I'm curious to hear what you guys, good loyal soccer fans who are born in America think.