The rational perspective here is that we don't have enough information to believe either persons account of what did or did not happen.
Very good--so let me ask this: Why should we default to "Well, there's not enough proof either way, so we might as well move ahead with the nomination" rather than "Well, there's not enough proof either way, so we might as well find someone else"?
Why is our default to proceed as though nothing happened?
I never said there couldn't be proof. There could be something, but I'm at a loss for something that would have last this many years. It's true that rape and sexual assault victims have been historically denied sufficient access to justice, but that doesn't mean we ignore the possibility of more past and future Crystal Mangums. Specifically now in this "MeToo Moment", we are beginning to see more and more claims about public figures. If it works, it will continue to happen. It hasn't worked until recently so we didn't see much of it. Bill Clinton is still allowed to leer at young women in full view of the public.
The alternative being that Bill Clinton should be... what, locked away?
Again, I'm not saying there's proof to imprison Kavanaugh.
On a completely separate line of thought: Should you be judged for your fitness to do anything in middle age based on drunken teenage behavior?
...Yes. Yes, you should--particularly when it's fitness to the "highest court in the land."
I got drunk plenty of times as a young high-schooler/undergrad. I never pinned a girl to a bed or forcibly held anyone down. For that matter, I never assaulted anyone, got a drunk driving arrest, or even fucking trespassed.
It is possible to be a decent human being and still get drunk. The problem here is that Kavanaugh is quite clearly not a decent human being.
Like all of the handwringing about the DECLINE OF DEMOCRACY we've been blasted with for the last two years?
It's not a decline of democracy. Democracy worked just fine. (see
this blog, second paragraph)
We haven't declined into anything; this is just a resurgence of the same old American greatness. It's been around for centuries.