The perfect Maiden line up would be:

[Profanity]

Vocals-Bruce Dickinson
guitars-Adrian Smith
guitars-Roland Grapow
Bass-Steve Harris
Drums-Ingo(old Helloween drummer)

 

[Soul O (Solo)]

I see you're still an asshole.

Dave Murray and Iron Maiden are synonymous. :metal:

 

[Rainking]

Replace members of Maiden with inferior musicians why?

 

[Nightwing]

The perfect Maiden line up is the one they have now minus Janick IMO.......not that I think Janick sucks, I just think the 3 guitars thing is a little lame, and superfluous.

 

[machine]

who's Roland Grapow??

 

[possessed]

We have already heard the perfect Maiden lineup...On the Killers album.

 

[Profanity]

who's Roland Grapow??

Helloween guitarist before Sascha joined Hello'

 

[Profanity]

We have already heard the perfect Maiden lineup...On the Killers album.

No, NOTB was a better lineup than Killers.

 

[possessed]

No, NOTB was a better lineup than Killers.

Noooooooooo! NOTB was the 2nd best lineup.

 

[Tormentor]

:hurl:

 

[EveryonesAWally]

cool

 

[Alex999]

The perfect Maiden line up is the one they have now minus Janick IMO.......not that I think Janick sucks, I just think the 3 guitars thing is a little lame, and superfluous.

What he said. I've got nothing against Janick, but they haven't made an excellent album with him yet.

 

[Rainking]

I like Jan alot - adds some flair to live proceedings.

 

[John Silver]

Helloween members in Maiden?
uke:

 

[The Real Moonchild]

Helloween members in Maiden?
uke:

He wanted more :cheddar: and happy fuckin songs in Maiden!!!!!!

 

[Nightwing]

I like Jan alot - adds some flair to live proceedings.

Yeah that's true enough - he is certainly the most animated of the guitarists. That stage presence might be missed.

I'll stick to the Harris/Murray/Dickinson/Smith/McBrain line up though.

 

[Reckless]

I say kick janick out and get yngwie that would be awesome.

 

[Alex999]

yngwie

Aren't 2 egos enough for the band?

 

[Reckless]

well yeah but they didn't say anythin about how much the band got along it just said what would be the best band and with maidens solo's yngwie would be perfect.

 

[Iron Maiden ROCKS!]

Smith/murray/harris/dickinson/mcbrain

Nowt against jan i just prefer H and Davey's styles