My personal favourite is Reise, Reise followed closely by Herzeleid. Mutter is good and same with Sehnsucht (which seems to be their most popular album by my estimation).
The problem with Rosenrot is that was basically just extra material reworked from Reise, Reise sessions so of course its a weaker album. I didn't mind it though.
I'll never really understand the whole simplicity argument. You're criticized if the music is too simple, or if it's too technical so either way it isn't going to please everyone - and that's great. Rammstein has always been a simple band especially on guitar, I mean guitar only plays a small part in their music after all.
The problem with Rosenrot is that was basically just extra material reworked from Reise, Reise sessions so of course its a weaker album. I didn't mind it though.
I'll never really understand the whole simplicity argument. You're criticized if the music is too simple, or if it's too technical so either way it isn't going to please everyone - and that's great. Rammstein has always been a simple band especially on guitar, I mean guitar only plays a small part in their music after all.